Arb021 decision on liability members of the tribunal. Ila international law association ilc articles international law commission, draft articles on responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts with comments, november 2001, supplement no. Shareholder protection in international investment law. Automatically by the icsid secretary general if requested in the application. Pursuant to section 2 of the arbitration act, a registered icsid award shall, as respects the pecuniary obligations which it imposes, be of the same force and effect for the purposes of execution as if it had been a judgment of the high court. Since a corporate entity may act as an investor, the question comes up. Karmer marble tourism construction industry and commerce limited liability company v. The icsid is part of and funded by the world bank group, headquartered in washington, d.
Designation of a constituent subdivision or agency is a requirement for icsid s jurisdiction over it. Eurogasor eurogas ii is a company incorporated under the laws of the. Responsibility of the state under international law for. This monograph is intended to give a solid overview of the international centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid and the principles of its functioning. The volume describes icsid s mandate, its organization and core functions, its arbitration and conciliation mechanisms, jurisdiction, recognition, and enforcement of icsid awards. Introduction in the world of international economic relations, disputes are bound to arise which require settlement mechanisms to ensure their effective resolution. The supporters of investment law, by contrast, for years have done too little to explain the benefits of system. Kilic insaat ithalat ihracat sanayi ve ticaret anonim sirketi v. Additionally, tecmed holds over 99% of the shares of cytrar, s. Convention on the settlement of investment disputes between states and nationals of other states, washington d. The convention on the settlement of investment disputes between states and nationals of other states icsid convention1 is often seen as setting forth a superior regime for compliance and enforcement of investment arbitration awards, particularly against states, as compared with other regimes for enforcement of such awards, such as, for example, the regime under the united nations. Company became its major shareholders never more than a small producer in the international oil industry it was eventually sold to a. Centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid on the basis of the agreement between the. Building international investment law wolters kluwer.
Rsm production corporation v republic of cameroon icsid case no. In a new icsid award, spains reforms of the renewable. The legal reasoning of icsid tribunals an empirical analysis. Leading cases from tke icsid, nafta, bilateral treaties ana customary international law edited by. International centre for settlement of investment disputes interinvest interinvest s. After a failed attempt at conciliation to resolve a dispute, rsm filed an icsid oil company arbitration request against the state of cameroon on july 20. Latin american states have consistently resisted the icsid stateinvestor dispute mechanism because they claim it favours investors. Chapter 1 dividends sections 205 207 chapter 2 accounts sections 209 223 chapter 3 audit sections 224 233b chapter 4 power of registrar to call for information,etc. Icsid international centre for settlement of investment disputes ip intellectual property lilly eli lilly and company, claimant. The legal effects of a denunciation of icsid institut fur. Challenges to arbitrators in icsid arbitration oxford.
A company established under the law of the host state will be disqualified, in principle, because it does not have the status of a foreign investor. Arb029 introductory note the decision on jurisdiction in champion trading company and others v. Tribunal finds pakistan breached fet, expropriation and nonimpairment obligations in the context of a mining joint venture with australian investor tethyan copper company tethyan copper company pty limited v. A common agenda 12 december 2005, paris room 1, oecd headquarters, paris defining investment and investor. The icsid convention on the settlement of investment disputes of 1965 the vienna convention on the law of treaties of 1969 salvadoran laws. Claimants and argentine republic respondent icsid case no. Stateowned enterprises as claimants in international. International investment law understanding concepts and. Reprinted in this booklet are the icsid convention, the report of the executive directors of the world bank on the convention, and the icsid regulations and rules as amended effective april 10, 2006. An additional icsid convention policy goal supporting the exclusion of statetostate disputes was the depoliticization of investment disputes, which is expressed most clearly in the prohibition on diplomatic protection under article 27 of the convention. The international centre for settlement of lnvestment disputes icsid or the centre was established on october 14, 1966 when its constituent treaty, the convention on the settlement of investment disputes between states and nationals of other states.
Let me briefly address three areas where i see problems with icsid s current practice. If the act of a stateowned entity cannot be attributed to the state, icsid does not have jurisdiction. Enforcing arbitration awards under the international. Tribunal finds pakistan breached fet, expropriation and. Icsi house, 22, institutional area, lodi road, new delhi 110 003. This chapter focuses on arbitrator challenges in international centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid arbitrations.
International centre for settlement of investment disputes. The uk high court of justice has enjoined a ukbased company, koza ltd. Has there been a breach of fair and equitable treatment. Ignacio torterola is codirector of international arbitration case law iacl and a partner in the international arbitration and litigation practice at gst llp. Arb0218, decision on jurisdiction, april 29, 2004 summary of the decision investor can include enterprises established in the home country and owned or controlled by nationals of the host country. Locally incorporated companies under foreign control.
It considers the requirements of the relevant provisions of the icsid convention, arbitral pronouncements on the relationship between those provisions, and some further specific issues raised in icsid arbitrations. The legal reasoning of icsid tribunals an empirical analysis 303 the tribunals interpretation. Arab republic of egypt was issued in a case brought to icsid by five claimants, two companies and three individuals, under the 1982 treaty. The companies act 20 is about improving corporate governance which revolves around the board of directors, senior management of the company, their roles. Icsid jurisdiction extends to matters of international investment, but the organizations charter never defines what actually qualfies as an investment. On december 2, 2019, an icsid tribunal found that spain complied with its ect obligations and that the claims raised by german investors were. Icsid international centre for settlement of investment disputes ifm ifm resources, inc. It is the first commentary to provide systematic articlebyarticle coverage not only of the convention itself, but also of the institution rules, the icsid arbitration rules and the icsid administrative and financial regulations. Indirect claims under the icsid convention penn law. A shareholder may own the company entirely, may own a majority of its shares or. Icsid lacks jurisdiction to arbitrate disputes between two private parties. The icsid convention requires that states designate their governmental agencies and constituent subdivisions to the centre, that is the icsid secretariat. Furthermore, it stated that the definition of corporate nationality in. But it could also become an additional step that is taken as a matter of routine and that further extends proceedings.
Jurisdiction and admissibility, icsid case no arb063, 18 april 2008, available at. In its halfcentury of existence icsid has administered more than 525 cases with parties, counsel, arbitrators, and conciliators from virtually every country in the world. Under cypriot law, a companys seat is determined by the location of its registered office. Understand the significance of the applicable law in icsid arbitration. Under article 251 of the icsid convention, the jurisdiction of icsid only extends to disputes between a contracting state and a national of another contracting state. One of the benefits of investment treaties and investment treaty arbitration is arguably their contribution to creating a rule of law framework for investment relations that is. Cytrar, a company incorporated under mexican law through which the investment giving rise to the disputes leading to these arbitration proceedings was made.
Introduction protection of shareholders under international law has been the subject of much controversy among scholars. The nationality of juridical persons in the icsid convention in light of its jurisprudence university of heidelberg, max planck institute for comparative public law and international law and the university of chile, march 2006 ricardo letelier astorga thesis advisor. Sections 234 234a chapter 5 investigation sections 235 251. Economics and business of the martin luther university hallewittenberg. The international centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid is the premier international investment arbitration facility in the world. Shareholder protection in international investment law by christoph schreuer i. International law has mainly dealt with the nationality of juridical. Nationality of juridical persons in the icsid convention. International centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid is an international arbitration institution established in 1966 for legal dispute resolution and conciliation between international investors. Professor nicolas boeglin reveals latin american countries are actively exploring alternatives to icsid and explains why bolivia, venezuela and ecuador have already withdrawn from the mechanism with argentina maybe joining them in the future. Indonesia 3, amco asia, a company registered in delaware, was. The definition of investment under the icsid convention. Practice notes for respondents in icsid arbitration. The jurisdiction of the centre shall extend to any legal dispute arising.
1239 257 211 612 249 396 630 183 1101 383 1364 1312 1263 28 765 1294 1571 938 400 187 899 487 887 1063 1064 1145 911 3 1317 682 263 1016 1266